Sindh High Court: A NIL Withholding Statement Can Cost IT Exporters Their Final Tax Regime Benefit

Sindh High Court: A NIL Withholding Statement Can Cost IT Exporters Their Final Tax Regime Benefit

PARTICULARS                                          DETAILS

Case:                               AC Technologies, Karachi v. The Commissioner Inland Revenue, Zone-III, Karachi

Citation:                         2026 SHC KHI 1932

Court:                             Sindh High Court, Karachi

Decision Date:               12 October 2026

Case Number:                ITRA No. 419 of 2025

Bench:                             Justice Agha Faisal & Justice Dr. Shah Nawaz Memon

Relevant tax Year:         2023

TL:DR:

 The Sindh High Court held that an IT exporter that filed a NIL withholding statement despite having deducted tax did not meet the conditions of Section 154A & lost the 0.25% Final Tax Regime. The error had not been corrected within the 60 days revision window under Section 165(2A).

INTRODUCTION:

Pakistan’s IT and IT-enabled services sectors play an important role in the country’s economy. They help Pakistan earn foreign exchange and create business opportunities around the world. To support these sectors, the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 provides tax benefits to eligible IT exporters under Section 154A. However, businesses must also comply with tax laws and fulfil all required reporting obligations to qualify for these benefits.

A recent decision by the Sindh High Court in the case of A.C. Technologies, Karachi v. The Commissioner Inland Revenue, Zone-III, Karachi raised an important legal question. Can an IT exporter still claim the Final Tax Regime (FTR) if it submits a NIL withholding tax statement despite having actually deducted and deposited withholding tax? The Court examined this issue & explained why businesses must provide accurate tax information to qualify for tax benefits.

Sections 154A provides tax benefits to eligible exporters of computer software, IT services and IT-enabled services who are registered with the Pakistan Software Export Board (PSEB).

Under this section, eligible IT exporters can pay a reduced withholding tax of 0.25% on their export income under the Final Tax Regime (FTR), provided they meet the legal requirements. Under the Normal Tax Regime, tax is calculated on taxable income after allowing permitted expenses and deductions. However, under the Final Tax Regime, the deducted tax is treated as the final tax on the relevant income.

So, this tax benefit is not available automatically. Section 154A(2) requires businesses to meet certain conditions, including filing their income tax returns and withholding tax statements. According to Section 154A(3), if these conditions are not fulfilled, the exporter may lose the benefit of the Final Tax Regime

Facts of the Case

A.C. Technologies was an association of persons engaged in exporting IT and IT-enabled services and was registered with PSEB. For Tax Year 2023, the company declared export receipts of Rs.229,906,949 and claimed taxation under Section 154A at 0.25%, amounting to Rs.574,767. During the assessment proceedings, the Inland Revenue Department examined the company’s withholding tax records through the FBR’s IRIS system. The investigation revealed that the company had made eight tax deductions relating to employees’ salaries under Section 149 and property rent under Section 155 during the first quarter of the relevant tax year. Surprisingly, the company had submitted a NIL withholding tax statement for that quarter, meaning that the actual deductions were not disclosed. Consequently, the department questioned whether the company had fulfilled the mandatory conditions for claiming the Final Tax Regime.

The central issue was whether submitting a NIL withholding tax statement could be considered valid compliance when actual tax deductions had already been made.

Questions of Law

  1. Whether filing a NIL withholding statement, despite having deducted tax, satisfies the requirements of Section 154A(2)(b) of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001?

2) Whether incorrect reporting in a withholding statement only attracts a penalty under Section 182, or can it also result in the      loss of Final Tax Regime benefits under Section 154A(3)?

Taxpayer’s Arguments

The taxpayer argued that it had fulfilled its tax obligations by deducting and paying withholding tax on the relevant transactions. According to the taxpayer, the NIL withholding statement was a reporting error and did not mean that no tax had actually been deducted or paid.

The taxpayer’s position was that such a reporting mistake should not automatically deprive it of the benefit of the Final Tax Regime, particularly when the relevant tax payments had been made. It maintained that the matter should be treated as a compliance or reporting issue rather than a reason to deny the reduced tax rate available under Section 154A.

COURT REASONING

•Legal Effect of Filing a Withholding Statement

•The 60 – Days Correction Period Under Section 165(2A)

•Distinguish b/w Penalties Under Section 182 & FTR Eligibility Under Section 154A

•Tax Calculated Under the Normal Tax Regime (NTR)

1. Legal Effect of Filing a Withholding Statement:-

The Court examined the requirements of Section 154A(2)(b) of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, read with Section 165. It observed that filing a withholding statement is not merely a procedural formality. The statement must accurately reflect the tax deducted during the relevant period.

In this case, the taxpayer had made withholding tax deductions but submitted a NIL quarterly statement. The Court did not accept

 this as compliance with the statutory reporting requirement.

2. The 60-Days Correction Period Under Section 165 (2A)

Section 165(2A) provides a mechanism for revising a withholding statement within the prescribed 60-day period. This provision allows taxpayers to correct inaccurate information within the statutory timeframe.

A taxpayer can correct a genuine mistake in a withholding statement within 60 days under Section 165(2A). However, in this case, the taxpayer did not correct the NIL statement within the allowed time, even though tax had actually been deducted. As a result, the incorrect statement remained unchanged.

3. Distinguish b/w Penalties Under Section 182 & FTR Eligibility Under Section 154A

The taxpayer’s position suggested that the reporting failure should be dealt with through a penalty under Section 182. The

penalty provision and the eligibility conditions for the Final Tax Regime are separate legal matters.

Section 182 deals with penalties for non-compliance, whereas Section 154A establishes the conditions for availing the Final Tax

 Regime. Therefore, the possibility of a penalty does not automatically mean that the taxpayer retains its eligibility for the FTR.

4. Tax Calculated Under the Normal Tax Regime (NTR)

The failure to fulfil the conditions of Section 154A resulted in the loss of the Final Tax Regime treatment. The matter proceeded

under the Normal Tax Regime. So, this does not mean that gross export receipts automatically become taxable income. Under the

 Normal Tax Regime, taxable income is calculated under the applicable tax provisions after considering admissible deductions and

 business expenses.

Final Judgement of the Honourable Sindh High Court:

After examining the facts, legal provisions and arguments presented by both parties, the Sindh High Court dismissed the

taxpayer’s reference application. The Court answered both legal questions against the taxpayer and in favor of the tax department.

The Court upheld the view that filing a NIL withholding statement despite making actual tax deductions did not fulfil the

 requirements of Section 154A(2)(b), read with Section 165 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001.

The Court further maintained that the taxpayer was not entitled to the Final Tax Regime benefit under Section 154A. The

 Tribunal’s direction to calculate the taxpayer’s taxable income under the Normal Tax Regime, after allowing admissible deductions

 and allowances, remained unchanged.

There was no order as to costs.

Conclusion:

Tax concessions under Section 154A are conditional, not automatic. Accurate quarterly withholding statements are a part of

 those conditions, and a NIL statement is only valid when nothing was deducted. Before the 60-day window under Section

165(2A) closes, reconcile your statements with your IRIS records and file a revised statement if needed.Disclaimer:

This article is for general information only and is not legal or tax advice. Please consult a qualified tax professional about your  specific situation

Leave a Reply